Topic: entertaining reviews comments

http://www.collective-zine.co.uk/reviews/?id=3850

and

http://www.collective-zine.co.uk/reviews/?id=8380

brilliant!

Re: entertaining reviews comments

Dan Mcadam · Meat Cutter at Whole Foods Market
these guys are great I saw them back in '87.

Re: entertaining reviews comments

Alex Deller's reviews are consistently wonderful.

We're going to party, karamu, fiesta, forever.

List/Listless: http://listless1.bandcamp.com

Re: entertaining reviews comments

a guy from 'from ashes rise' took offence at kjetil's review and posted a snarky comment on twitter, which was subsequently deleted, probably when he realised that an old dude in a punk  band probably shouldn't care about middling reviews of their band. fortunately my phone's twitter app saved it for posterity and i could retweet it. smile

Re: entertaining reviews comments

Andy Malcolm wrote:

a guy from 'from ashes rise' took offence at kjetil's review and posted a snarky comment on twitter, which was subsequently deleted, probably when he realised that an old dude in a punk  band probably shouldn't care about middling reviews of their band. fortunately my phone's twitter app saved it for posterity and i could retweet it. smile


i saw that, what a loser... it wasn't even a bad review and in fact most of it actually was complimentary. it's one thing to react to a bad review but to an average review makes you look a right tosser. that record is rubbish as well.

Re: entertaining reviews comments

good work MH!

http://www.collective-zine.co.uk/reviews/?id=8839

Re: entertaining reviews comments

"the band speaks for itself"

then don't bother sending it out for reviews

Re: entertaining reviews comments

Top review for Hands Out Andy!

Re: entertaining reviews comments

thanks smile

Re: entertaining reviews comments

the good captain's "unconvential" reviewing style is drawing ire

http://www.collective-zine.co.uk/reviews/?id=8858

Re: entertaining reviews comments

In all fairness that review might be the kookiest thing I've ever read.

Added: 07-02-2013 18:26:05

it's also really random

Sky:Lark (Noisy Post-Hardcore) - http://skylark.bandcamp.com
Man Hands (Fastcore) - http://horsepartyrules.bandcamp.com

Re: entertaining reviews comments

i am not necessarily a fan of a one line review myself but i will defend the writer's right to write it smile

Re: entertaining reviews comments

It's quite an interesting review but it is very 'Vice 2008'

Re: entertaining reviews comments

stinging. i have no idea if fidanza read vice in 2008 though.

Re: entertaining reviews comments

I honestly remember reading a Vice a few years ago and it had that exact review in it but about a different band/member leaving