A horrible hack

She Sir


Year Released: 2010
Format: 7"
Label: indiecater
Reviewed by Andy Malcolm on Aug 21, 2010
4 songs on this EP, and it feels that for the most part they are far too short. Opener "Ginger" barely troubles 90 seconds, which for such a gentle indie pop / shoegaze thing is simple not going to cut it. Fluttering vocals, pleasant guitar strums and an air similar to the Pains of Being Pure at Heart, it glides to a halt before I am, or it for that matter, is ready. Fortunately "Lemongrass" is a more sensible length, at around two and a half minutes, which is much more sensible. This one brings together soft male and female vocals, working well in tandem over the typically dreamy backing hums and synths. Definitely the pick of the tracks here. Then there is "Golden Ways", which doesn't really quite come together as a fully formed song, failing to hook me in despite some nice bits that then fall away into inconsequential 'gazing. The short EP is brought to a close on "Boystown" which also doesn't feel like a completely fleshed out idea, fading away into obscurity before it ever got going. I guess this release is intended as a taster for the band rather than a fully fledged release, and it serves that purpose reasonably well. There are some moments that hint at better things to come at least.

Share this:

Related Reviews

Various - December 24th
December 24th
indiecater, 2013

"It was Christmas Eve babe"